I have traded with Ameritrade for over 20 years I think and so I may be a little partial. I like both for different reasons and some features I didn’t like. If you love to trade Options and Money is no Option (sorry), then Optionsexpress is for you. They have won numerous awards and deserve them. The option pricing history feature is exceptional. Also, the tool that compares various types of trades, IE.. covered calls, spreads – long, vertical, etc. is fabulous. I can’t say enough about this feature. I have used TOS (think or swim) much too complicated. Even when I was making trades in my other accounts I would switch back to my old optionsexpress account to look at the various option combinations I could concoct. Seeing the profit loss in graphic form and seeing the time erosion factors was phenomenal. I still recommend checking this out.
What i didn’t like about optionsexpress is minor if you are a serious trader is that there per trade cost was slightly more than other programs. I think an option trade used to cost $9.99 plus $1.75 per contract. This can be expensive if you are low dollar and just starting out.
The other thing I didn’t like and it may just be my own personality is this. That the software is so great and cool that it can tempt you into overconfidence and therefor you over trade, over commit and can easily wipe out your account if you don’t have discipline. This was my own experience, so if you don’t suffer from my personality flaw and you have lots of money to trade this could be a great trading site for you.
Ameritrade, Now TdAmeritrade:
is by far the best trader site for everyone in a general sense. What I mean is they are great for beginners, very conservative, reasonable cost structure and have vast aray of help and wide selection of services offered. Again, I’m partial and loyal. I will keep my Tdameritrade account forever. I had used them for my first rollover IRA, I learned to trade Mutual Funds first. Well I have to admit, I let the phone rep suggest a few funds and these turned out to be top performers. After that I had learned some stock trading on my own and had the normal experiance of beginners. Some sucess and some dissasters, I didn’t know how to interpret the news information that is broadcast, I didn’t know how to read fundimentals, I didn’t know how to read sector trends, I didn’t know how to interpret geo political events, I admit it I didn’t know much if anything. When I had success I thought I was a genuis. When I lost I though what eversource I listen to lied and betrayed me. Sorry I’m rambling ( I talk trading basics another time).
So for beginners the trading site is very, very, very USER FREINDLY. I liked thier phone support. They have great help. It is easy to see your trades when they are up or down. You can see your entire portfolio. You can get great market information. Don’t let me forget… I remember know they were the first site I used that had great quote information. NEWBEES pay attention, when you learn to trade you have to absolutely must have good qoutes. Otherwise you might as well send your buys and sell orders through the mail (a little exaturation), so you get the point.
They are still my favorite site because they do so many things right. You can have possible any type of an account and it is very easy. EASY, I guess that is the one word that sums up TdAmeritrade is that they are the best for part time traders, retiree’s, begineers, and every one in general.
SPECIAL FEATURES AT TDAMERITRADE
What you may not know is that they have some very good free professional tools, Stockscreener, they have a charting service and program trading. I can’t think of the name right now, darn… Lets see its on my other computer – STRATEGY DESK. I can’t believe they give this out free, its very good stuff. I learned a few programming tricks. Most of all I lean on the technical analysis side of things, I liked reviewing the charts manually on my favorite charts. If you like to trade premarket and want to trade gaps this could be a good source for you. A great site to use Power Trading.
Ok what I didn’t like about TdAmeritrade.
I started to trade options heavily. I was trading 100 or 400 option contracts at a time. That gets kind of expensive if you pay a fee per option. So found a few new sites, OptionHouse, ThinkorSwim (tos), and Terra Nova. OptionHouse is the place to go trade hundreds of option contracts because they don’t charge per option, but be warned they are not user freindly or not nearly as proffessional as the other sites. One of my favorites for heavy traders is TerraNova tell them I sent ya. TOS is really a great site, I just think its too complicated. TOS is more for the person who was a protrader and has odles of computers and monitors. It was not easy to learn. Well another time I explain all the sites pros and cons. I hope this is helpfull. If you have something you want to add please fell free to add in the comment field.